Quantum Immortality

Quantum Immortality

The original concept of quantum immortality was first published in 1987 by Hans Moravec. It is directly implied by  the Many Worlds interpretation of quantum theory by Hugh Everett (1957). He noticed that it was an implication of quantum theory, and although he did not write about quantum immortality it is clear he expected to live forever.

Many Worlds

It is increasingly accepted that the universe includes all possible worlds, as described by Everett. This means that with every event that actually happens in the world, the other possible versions of that event happen too, in other, parallel versions of the world. Thus as Everett stated, the reality of the individual is a branching tree of possible sequences of events. Just two outcomes are illustrated in this picture, courtesy of Max Tegmark. When Bob asks Alice out for a drink, both outcomes actually happen, in different versions of the world.

This leads directly to the idea of quantum immortality. Whenever you might die at the next moment, there is always an alternative moment, a different variation of reality, in which you survive. Since there is nothing to experience in the version of reality where you die, you only ever experience the one where you survive. As Marcus Chown states:

If the Many Worlds is correct, it seems the only certainty in life is not death but immortality. We’re all gonna live forever. (2002, 40)

Russian Roulette is often used as an example. There are six possible positions of the bullet, so mechanically there are six possible outcomes. In five of them you just hears the gun just go click. There is a lot more noise in the other outcome, but you cannot hear it because in this version of reality you no longer exist. But as there is nothing to experience in that version of reality, you inevitably experience one of the other five. That is the theory. It is examined in colourful detail in the article Does Quantum Theory Imply You Are Immortal?.

That is the standard idea of quantum immortality. In a quantum world all possibilities are real, and there is always some variation of reality in which you survive. Schrödinger’s cat is a perfect example. In one version of the world he dies, but in another survives.Max Tegmark has examined this idea in some depth, and he describes it in his New Scientist interview with Marcus Chown Dying to Know. (That article is behind a paywall, but Tegmark reproduces it on his site – it is about a third of the way down his page The Universes of Max Tergmark.)

The Moravec Jump

This kind of idea is seldom taken seriously for a number of reasons. Primarily it is unimaginable if it is taken literally. If we just go on and on and on, the body must fail more and more, but somehow go on living. We would turn out like the characters in Death Becomes Her. Their bodies start to literally fall apart, but they continue to get up to mischief.

Clearly that does not happen, and the reason is that a different kind of event happens first. As Moravec states, when we die:

We lose our ties to physical reality, but, in the space of all possible worlds, that cannot be the end. Our consciousness continues to exist in some of those, and we will always find ourselves in worlds where we exist and never in ones where we don’t. (1998)

In other words, given the universe of all possible worlds, there is inevitably a version of the world in which there is a logical continuation of your experience of reality. So the experience of death in this world leads straight on to the experience of life in the next world.

This does seem more like science fiction. But although this is a major stretch of the imagination, given the nature of consciousness it must be right. Consciousness is to the space of all possible worlds as a computer system is to all of its memory. The computer can access any place in the memory, and it can jump from one point to another. It can play Part 1 of a movie from one block of memory then continue straight on and play Part 2 of the movie from a different block of memory. Consciousness does exactly the same thing except that each part of the ‘movie’ is a lifetime in the space of all possible worlds. When there is an end to one lifetime, consciousness simply experiences the lifetime that makes the most natural continuation, wherever that happens to exist in the universe. So death is not the end. It is just a jump from this lifetime to the next. I call it the Moravec jump.

The Functional Identity

One can imagine getting a new body, but surely you have to have the same mind to be the same person. Effectively, you do. The consciousness Moravec is referring to is actually the world hologram, the product of access consciousness. It is this that must exist in the space of all possible worlds.  But can just the world hologram, the memories of a lifetime, constitute a whole person? It not only can, it does. This is another rather massive new idea. As described in Identity, even the physical body is indeterminate except where observed. This means that on the inside view, in the reality you know as the world, the world hologram is what you really are.

It helps to make sense of this the state of the memory holds more than just the record of observations in a literal sense. As Deutsch states, it is not only all the memory of one’s life that is contained in the world hologram, but also the particular way one processes information. Just as all the knowledge about the world and oneself is contained in the world hologram, so too is every aspect of the character, and how one thinks and makes decisions:

…  every last scrap of our knowledge ― including our knowledge of the non-physical worlds of logic, mathematics and philosophy, and of imagination, fiction, art and fantasy ― is encoded in the form of programs for the rendering of those worlds on our brain’s own virtual-reality generator. (1997, 121)

In other words the ‘functional identity’, meaning the character and the psychology, what you are like, how you think, are all defined in the world hologram. So all the attributes of the mind that make up the identity are defined in the world hologram. In terms of character, memory, beliefs and criteria, you are the world hologram.

Real Immortality

What will it be like? As Deutsch explains, with advanced technology it is possible to make complete, functional human bodies:

Illness and old age are going to be cured soon – certainly within the next few lifetimes … by creating backups of the states of brains, which could be uploaded into new, blank brains in identical bodies if a person should die. (2011, 455)

Somewhere in the space of all possible worlds, some society in the future will be using this technology to make new people, complete with adult characters and capabilities. They can give each body a character by uploading an adult world hologram into the brain, a record of a lifetime of experiences. Let’s say they want a broad spectrum of characters, so they make sure that this initialisation is random. 

Because the initialisation of the character is random, in the universe of all possible worlds, every possibility will actually happen. So in one of these worlds, it is your world hologram, exactly as it is at the moment of your death, that gets used to initialise this brand new body. So you are the one that wakes up in this new body, next moment after death.

Of course, this is fantastically improbable, but it happens only as survival in the existing body becomes vastly more unlikely. The improbability of one’s survival climbs and climbs as one gets older, and at a certain point, where survival would be theoretically possible but monumentally unlikely, the Moravec jump occurs. Your experience jumps to a next moment elsewhere in the space of all possible worlds.

The logic is very simple in IT terms. Each observation made is essentially a computation, the addition of that structure of information to the body of information of the world hologram. The effect of this computation is that the frame of reference defines this individual as existing in a later moment in time. Quantum immortality essentially holds that if there is any possible version of a next moment that instantiates such a world hologram, then, since that is all that is available to be experienced, that is what gets experienced. The Moravec jump applies the same logic, but with a whole extra class of possibilities to choose from.
In quantum immortality, we are only looking at all the possibilities in a specific reality, the branching of a specific world-line. So all the possible next moments have to be possible versions of the next moment, in this reality. Moravec is pointing out that it is not just this physical reality which could be experienced in the next moment, but any physical reality. As described in Time & Quantum Time, this follows directly from the quantum concept of time. As Deutsch states:”… ‘other times in our universe’ are distinguished from ‘other universes’ only from our perspective, and only in that they are closely related to ours by the laws of physics. (1997, 278)”. As he explains, this is the central concept of the quantum concept of time.
Instead of the next moment in this physical reality, the next moment could be a moment in any physical reality, provided that it contains the world hologram of this individual. And Moravec’s point is that in the space of all possible worlds, there must, inevitably, be physical worlds where exactly this world hologram is present in that world, for whatever reason.

You die. You wake up. Somewhere. This is one of the greatest revelations in the meaning of the new physics we have discovered. In the light of an eternity of lifetimes everything is different. We are infants compared to what we will become in due course.  As we now know our bodies are stardust, quite literally. The truth about the true identity of each individual is even more marvellous. The world hologram is the soul. And we are worlds in action. Each one of us is the experiencing of a specific human reality, a movie of life, by the universe itself. We are parallel realities, worlds among Everett’s many worlds. We are immortal, empowered, and we have free will. All we have to do is get with the programme. We are constantly evolving. What we will become in time we can barely begin to imagine. Time to wake up and take a hand.